Showing posts with label legal profession. Show all posts
Showing posts with label legal profession. Show all posts

Thursday, December 1, 2016

Thought Provoking Law Quote: Hermione Granger

The popular Harry Potter book series featured the exploits of a group of teenage wizards as they navigate the travails of life, friendship, evil forces, and magical education at the Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. An ongoing theme throughout the series focuses on the forces of dark magic and the danger presented to society by a particularly powerful dark wizard known as Voldemort. Harry and his friends, including the very bright Hermione Granger, have discovered that Voldemort’s presence was once again threatening danger to society and they had reported it to the appropriate governmental authorities. However, in order to avoid a public panic, the government has not merely ignored their entreaties to take action, but has engaged in an aggressive campaign to discredit the young wizards and their statements. In this setting, the following exchange takes place between Hermione Granger and Minister of Magic Rufus Scrimgeour:

"'Are you planning to follow a career in Magical Law, Miss Granger?’ asked Scrimgeour. ‘No, I am not,’ retorted Hermione. ‘I’m hoping to do some good in the world!'"


From her point of reference in the eternal struggle between good and evil, Hermione conceptualized law as an impediment to the accomplishment of good.  In her eyes, law was bad and to “do good” one had to do something other than law.  Considering law through Hermione’s eyes introduces us to the complexity of the question, “What is law?”

Friday, November 18, 2016

Law School Songs

Stressed, worried, impoverished, insecure, feeling inadequate, intimidated, exhausted, disappointed, overworked . . . welcome to the law, young people..





Wednesday, October 19, 2016

Is Civil Litigation a Level Playing Field?

Click on the link here to watch a Yahoo Finance reporter suggest that the employee lawsuit filed against Wells Fargo for enforcing unrealistic sales goals necessitating unethical conduct is likely bogus because "It was filed by a one-man law firm."  If the rules of civil litigation made a level playing field, then this would not be relevant.  If courts were really the great levellor where any person can take on a powerful party and have a real chance at justice, this would not be relevant.

Since it is apparently relevant, then maybe those other things are not true.

In the movie clip below from "The Rainmaker," sole practitioner Rudy Baylor tries to take a corporate deposition of the defendant insurance company represented by a "big" law firm.

Thursday, September 29, 2016

The Charisma Matrix

With lawyering, as with many critical service professions like physicians, psychologists, nuclear scientists, pre-school teachers, accountants, etc. it is apparently far better to look good than to be good.  Impressions trump substance.  So, access the Charisma Matrix:

 

Monday, May 11, 2015

Bad Lawyer Ads (Just Kidding)

It's the end of the semester.  Usually I post some of the latest "Bad Lawyer Ads" for the duration.  This year, the post is just for fun from the fictional Saul Goodman.  Have a great summer.  See you in the Fall.







Thursday, April 30, 2015

Thought Provoking Law Quote: The Devil's Dictionary

American Writer Ambrose Bierce must have had some difficult dealings with the legal system.  His Devil's Dictionary published in 1906 includes the following definitions of legal terms:

LITIGATION, n. A machine which you go into as a pig and come out of as a sausage.

LITIGANT, n. A person about to give up his skin for the hope of retaining his bones.

LAWYER, n. One skilled in circumvention of the law.


CORPORATION, n. An ingenious device for obtaining individual profit without individual responsibility.

There are many more.  Click here to browse for your favorites.

Friday, January 30, 2015

Monday, November 24, 2014

More Bad Lawyer Ads

Just to be clear, it's the ads that are bad.  I make no representations about the lawyers.

It's Thanksgiving break week, so there are no substantive posts this week. But in keeping with tradition, there are bad ads. Click here for earlier posts in the series.

It is basketball season, after all:



Wednesday, March 26, 2014

Contempt of Court

Students who watch the movie, My Cousin Vinny, are sometimes surprised by the contempt rulings against Vinny for failing to comply with courtroom decorum and question whether that is merely a fictional device to garner laughs.  Well, here is Judge Joe Brown, formerly of TV curt show fame, found in contempt of court and sent to jail as a result of his courtroom conduct. It happens.

Raw audio:




Monday, March 24, 2014

Pay The Piper, or He Sings

From the fable of A-Rod and the MLB:

If you into a serious legal dispute, you need a lawyer.  If you need a  lawyer, then you need to pay a lawyer's fee.  If you don't pay the fee, then you get into a legal dispute with the lawyer who helped you with your legal dispute.  If you get into a legal dispute with the lawyer who helped you with your legal dispute, then your lawyer will disclose all the secrets that he hid for you in order to prove that you needed a lawyer's help with your legal dispute. To try to safeguard those secrets, you will need a lawyer to help you with the legal dispute with the lawyer who helped you with your legal dispute. And the carousel spins round and round again, etc.


Tuesday, January 21, 2014

Perception of American Law

The video below was submitted by Konrad Lee at Utah State University. In case you missed it about 30 years ago, this scenario builds on the story, long since discredited, that a woman whose precious family pet died when she attempted to dry it off in a microwave oven prosecuted a successful lawsuit against the microwave manufacturer. I've decided to open class with this one today.

Sadly, this is an expression of how some perceive American Justice.

Tuesday, October 15, 2013

More Legal Fallout From Anonymous Internet Postings


In 2011, five New Orleans police officers were convicted of civil rights violations in the shootings and deaths of several New Orleans residents in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina. A few weeks ago, U.S. District Court judge threw out the convictions on the basis of "grotesque prosecutorial misconduct."  Before and during the trial, lawyers in the U.S. Attorney's office that was prosecuting the case posted anonymous online comments to the New Orleans Times Picayune site (nola.com) creating a "prejudicial, poisonous atmosphere." Another lawyer in the Dept. of Justice in Washington DC who had helped prepare the case for trial also posted anonymously to comment on the case.

Lawyers, and certainly prosecutors, are aware that such public comment is against all rules of professional conduct.  Yet, somehow, the anonymity that appears to shield the comments from attribution somehow alter conduct - and not for the better.  I have previously commented on how internet anonymity skews the balance between the liberty of expression and the liberty of privacy.  In this case, it corrupted due process.

I am a staunch supporter of the liberty of expression.  However, I can't for the life of me understand how anonymous expression has value that adds to the discourse.  The old radio show, The Shadow, carried the catch phrase, "Who knows what evil lurks in the hearts of men?" Anonymity allows the evil to be outed. If you want to speak badly of others or their opinions, you should have the liberty to do so.  But only if you are willing to face the criticism that comes with the expression of your opinions.

If expression is so important (and it is) why do we allow it to be cheapened by anyone's fleeting tawdry ill considered ramblings? Do we allow bills to be introduced in a legislature with anonymous sponsors? Do judges render opinions anonymously? Do doctors render diagnoses anonymously? Do general direct battles anonymously? Newspapers will not print letters to the editor without first making some reasonable effort to verify the source. That has been the journalistic standard for decades - an improvement over the 19th century practice of printing letters with pseudonyms. But on the most groundbreaking technology, we have gone backwards in the theory of valued civilized discourse.

Now, even lawyers can't keep themselves from botching their own cases by blabbing on the internet.

Tuesday, September 24, 2013

No Laughing Matter

The LSCB previously commented on the trials of comic Vince August, a/k/a South Hackensack, New Jersey municipal judge, Vince Sicari. Previously ordered by the State Ethics Board to give up one of the jobs, Vince appealed to the state Supreme Court.  The court ruled unanimously against him.

Yahoo news reports:

"In the course of his routines, Sicari has demeaned certain people based on national origin and religion and has revealed his political leanings," according to the court's opinion. "The court cannot ignore the distinct possibility that a person who has heard a routine founded on humor disparaging certain ethnic groups and religions will not be able to readily accept that the judge before whom he or she appears can maintain the objectivity and impartiality that must govern all municipal court proceedings."

...and that is no laughing matter.

According to the New York Times, Sicari has resigned the judgeship, leaving behind his $13,000 annual income.

"Now appearing, Vince August."
"Thank you, ladies and gentlemen.  I'll be here all week."

source of image: http://cliffviewpilot.com/south-hackensack-judge-takes-the-standup-with-the-supremes/ 

Oyay! Oyay! Oyay! Now presiding, the Honorable Judge Vincent Sicari:

source of image: http://comedybeat.com/jan2020_articles/njlj_judge_sicari_barred_from_stage_10-18-2010.html

Thursday, April 11, 2013

Hardcore Egomaniacal Lawyers

It can be a fine line between being confident and being self-aggrandizing. Lawyers, schmoozed by a slick advertising agency, can have some trouble staying on the right side of the line.

Thursday, April 4, 2013

Bad Lawyer Ads # ... (I lost track)

This ad appears to be generic ( the "Lawyer & Lawyer" firm name at the end I guess means "Put you firm name here.") But in the YouTube description there is a link that brings you to an actual law firm.

There is nothing that inspires confidence and signifies relief for facing foreclosure more than the image of a break dancing guinea pig.

Monday, March 4, 2013

Is This Another Lawyer Joke?

A judge and a stand-up comedian go to the movies but they only need one ticket. Why is that? Because they are the same person!

In 2008, part time New Jersey municipal court judge, Vince Sicari (a/k/a Vince August), was ordered by the ethics commission to give up his "day" job as a stand-up comic. Sicari has appealed the ruling and the New Jersey Supreme Court heard arguments last week. Read the NY Times article here for details.

In my opinion, having a judge with a sense of humor is a plus.

Wednesday, February 27, 2013

We Owe a Lot to Lindsay Lohan

There are a few important contributors to the law who seem to pop up  as examples or exemplars in my Legal Environment course on more than a few occasions during the semester. If I give it some thought, I can readily name a few that come to mind; Justices Oliver Wendell Holmes, Benjamin Cardozo and Antonin Scalia, Presidents John Adams, Woodrow Wilson and Abraham Lincoln, Economic Philosopher Adam Smith, and commentators Bill O'Reilly and Stephen Colbert and, of course, Lindsay Lohan.

With the addition of the case described below, the actress and celebrity accounts for three separate examples of legal principles applied to real facts.  First, there was the lawsuit for civil assault brought against her by the passenger in a car that she apparently chased at high speeds through the streets of LA in 2007; an incident that also resulted in her arrest.  It allows for explanation of all the elements of civil assault - apprehension or fear of imminent bodily harm without the element of physical contact.

Then, there was the $10M lawsuit against e-trade that was the subject of this post.

And now we have a federal court ruling in a lawsuit that Ms. Lohan brought against musical artist "Pit Bull" for the use of her name in the lyrics of his song, Give Me Everything.

This is insane: the way the name growin'

According to the complaint, the use of Ms. Lohan's name in the above quoted lyrics constituted an alleged violation of NY State Civil Rights law, and gave rise to claims for unjust enrichment and intentional infliction of emotional distress. Not surprisingly, the Defendant's 12(b)(6) motion was granted. Judge Hurley's decision may be read here. The lyrics are protected from the Civil Rights claim as artistic expression and fall well below the liability threshold of "extreme and outrageous conduct."

Although he rejected the imposition of sanctions under Rule 11 for filing a frivolous claim, the judge did not let plaintiff's counsel off the hook. His order imposes a $750 fine for alleged misrepresentations in a letter to the court and an additional $750 for filing an Opposition Brief with content plagiarized from websites and  prior filings and missing legal citation.

So, my thanks goes out to Lindsay Lohan.  Her contributions to the law allow my students to see past the stuffy and stayed reputation of the law as the province of dead rich white guys.

Give Me Everything by Pit Bull and friends: