Law affects the conduct of the people. But if the people use their conduct to peacefully disobey the law, then maybe the people affect the shape of the law.
Rosa Parks. She sat on a bus.
videos, music, websites, articles, movies, and popular culture resources for use in the undergraduate law classroom
Showing posts with label natural law. Show all posts
Showing posts with label natural law. Show all posts
Friday, October 18, 2013
Friday, April 26, 2013
Imagining a Modern Bill of Rights
Here's an interesting exercise: If your students were to re-write the Bill of Rights from scratch, what would it include? If we drafted a new constitution every 20 years, as Jefferson may have suggested, what would be included in the latest draft among the concept of fundamental liberties?
Tuesday, January 17, 2012
More Law/Justice Disconnect
In 1998, David Messenger of Chaplin, Connecticut bludgeoned his pregnant wife to death in front of their 5 year old child. He was subsequently found not guilty of manslaughter by reason of insanity and committed for 20 years to the custody of the State of Connecticut Psychiatric Security Review Board. As the PSRB considers releasing Messenger into a halfway house to complete his sentence, the Hartford Courant reveals that Messenger posseses significant financial assets; including, incredibly, a portion of the $425,000 proceeds from the settlement of the wrongful death case filed against him by his wife's estate! In the loopiest of legal loopholes:
State Probate Court Administrator Paul Knierim said there is nothing in the probate statutes that prohibits people found not guilty by reason of insanity from remaining as beneficiaries of the estates of their victims.
Is the court devoid of equitable powers to remedy this travesty? The Courant article reports further:
And because David Messenger voluntarily gave up his parental rights to his son, after he killed his wife, the boy wasn’t eligible to challenge Messenger’s standing as the beneficiary of the estate.
Once again, how can this be? The son is still a beneficiary of his mother's estate. Why can't he challenge the status of other beneficiaries? If this article and the scenario that it paints is perplexing to legal professionals, how must it be perceived by the general public?
The law is not inherently equal to justice. Justice must be avidly pursued by a vigilant society.
The following video was posted on YouTube in 2008 by the family of Messenger's victim:
State Probate Court Administrator Paul Knierim said there is nothing in the probate statutes that prohibits people found not guilty by reason of insanity from remaining as beneficiaries of the estates of their victims.
Is the court devoid of equitable powers to remedy this travesty? The Courant article reports further:
And because David Messenger voluntarily gave up his parental rights to his son, after he killed his wife, the boy wasn’t eligible to challenge Messenger’s standing as the beneficiary of the estate.
Once again, how can this be? The son is still a beneficiary of his mother's estate. Why can't he challenge the status of other beneficiaries? If this article and the scenario that it paints is perplexing to legal professionals, how must it be perceived by the general public?
The law is not inherently equal to justice. Justice must be avidly pursued by a vigilant society.
The following video was posted on YouTube in 2008 by the family of Messenger's victim:
Monday, January 16, 2012
Civil Disobedience Exposes Law's Injustice
In honor of Martin Luther King, Jr. Day, below are a couple of videos celebrating the acts of civil disobedience performed by the Freedom Riders in Jackson, Mississippi in 1961. These, and other acts of peaceful civil disobedience help expose and publicize the injustice of segregation law to the nation and its national government.
The law is not inherently equal to justice. Justice must be avidly pursued by a vigilant society.
The law is not inherently equal to justice. Justice must be avidly pursued by a vigilant society.
Tuesday, August 30, 2011
Justice Scalia Says Natural Law is Relative
According to Justice Scalia's comments in the video below, "Natural Law" is whatever the majority says it is. So, if the majority decides that same sex marriage (for example) is not to be allowed, then that is what "nature" dictates. It follows, then, that if the majority votes that public corporations should not have the same free speech rights as natural persons, then that should be law, despite constitutional protection (as interpreted by the Supreme Court). In reading Justice Scalia's comments during oral arguments and his decisions, one would conclude that Justice Scalia fancies himself an historian. How many times in the course of American history has "natural law" been used to justify denial of basic rights to unpopular minorities? In a democracy, is there not a need for an institution that protects against the tyranny of the majority?
Justice Scalia also queries what qualities of judges make them more qualified to determine what the law is than the democratic majority. This video can be a good device to raise the counter-majoritarion difficulty for class.
Justice Scalia also queries what qualities of judges make them more qualified to determine what the law is than the democratic majority. This video can be a good device to raise the counter-majoritarion difficulty for class.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)